Governments opened a five-day conference in Geneva on Monday to decide whether the world should start negotiating binding rules for weapons that can select and attack targets on their own. The Seventh Review Conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons runs from November 16 to 20 at the Palais des Nations, and lethal autonomous weapons systems are its central issue. Reuters reported on the opening day that the United States and Russia look set to oppose a push to launch negotiations on legally binding rules, even though most of the convention's 128 states parties support them.
The systems at issue are not drones flown by a remote pilot. A weapon can navigate automatically while a person still chooses the target and decides whether to strike. The concern in Geneva is the next step: a system switched on by a person that then selects and engages a target without another human decision. Advances in artificial intelligence have accelerated the development of autonomous drones, robots, tanks and submarines, and semi-autonomous weapons have already been used in Ukraine, Sudan and the Middle East.
The conference chair has proposed a two-year mandate under which a group of governmental experts would negotiate a new protocol and submit a draft to the 2028 meeting of states parties, with an update in 2027. No treaty is expected this week. The decision delegates face is narrower and still consequential: whether formal negotiations should begin at all, and what form they should take.
Washington favours a different path. The United States has proposed a five-year process that would produce a non-binding agreement, arguing that existing international humanitarian law already provides a framework for governing these weapons. Israel has also rejected calls for binding restrictions. Russia has previously opposed a binding agreement and had not publicly set out its position for this round, Reuters reported.
On the other side, the International Committee of the Red Cross argues that existing humanitarian law does not sufficiently address the specific risks of autonomous weapons and is calling for specific rules to ensure meaningful human control. In August, United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres and Red Cross President Mirjana Spoljaric renewed a joint appeal first made in 2023. They called for two prohibitions, covering systems whose effects users cannot predict and anti-personnel systems that deliberately target human beings, with strong restrictions on other systems to preserve human judgment.
A middle position may decide the week. Human Rights Watch said the United Kingdom, Germany and France support opening negotiations without committing in advance to a legally binding outcome. Two diplomats told Reuters that talks would be difficult but that an agreement combining binding and non-binding elements could offer a way forward.
The groundwork is unusually complete. The convention's expert group, created in 2016, adopted its final report by consensus on September 4, 2026, ending a three-year mandate, and one paragraph is described as the first agreed consensus characterization of a lethal autonomous weapon system. At the previous review conference in December 2021, states did not agree to schedule negotiations.
For readers watching the outcome on Friday, the wording will matter more than the headlines. A mandate to negotiate a protocol gives experts a named document to bring back in 2028. A mandate to explore measures or develop guidelines returns analysis instead. Either could be described as progress, but only one starts the process that could eventually require governments to accept binding limits on machines that choose their own targets.
Photo: The Palais des Nations in Geneva, Switzerland, photographed by Gryffindor via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.